Jamaica Gleaner / Is this column biased towards consumers? Is it unfair to the insurance industry? The unfairness argument suggests that the things I write about are mostly anti-insurance industry.
The feedback was a passing comment from a former industry employee.
“My friends in the insurance industry don’t like you,” she remarked.
The statement was made in the context of a discussion about an article I wrote a few weeks ago. Political opinion writers face similar problems. They are either pro-JLP and anti-PNP at one time, or pro-PNP and anti-JLP at another.
The choice of the label often provides clues about the perspective of the person who assigns it. There are only two colours: green or orange. The choices are always binary.
If this column has an orientation, it is pro-consumerist. Unashamedly. Former head of Canada’s insurance regulatory agency Lawrie Savage offers the reasoning for my point of view.
He puts it this way: “contractual complexities tend to put the insurer in a position of strength when it comes time to settle a claim. The insurer has the legal and financial resources to dispute a claim, even if on a technicality. Also, the insurer has possession of the funds, and the policyholder is dependent on the insurer to gain access to them. By unfairly resisting claims, an irresponsible insurer can, therefore, retain funds rightly due to policyholders, and it can be difficult for policyholders to protect themselves against such abuses.”
Mr Savage’s comments are based on his experiences in Canada and his study of insurance practices in Latin America and the Caribbean.
“Putting fair treatment at the heart of insurance” was the headline of the article that I wrote on December 17. The subtext: an admission by an Insurance Association of Jamaica official that some insurers charge honest customers for fraud committed by dishonest persons as the sole strategy to combat the problem.
This was not the default “solution” in pro-consumer jurisdictions.
My piece omitted to ask two important questions: Is the insurance industry subject to the provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, the CPA? Is its practice of charging honest consumers or policyholders for fraud committed by dishonest persons in the absence of strategies to combat the problem consistent with the aims of the legislation?
Many persons, including insurance industry employees, are unaware that Parliament passed a law in 2005 it was updated seven years later to protect all consumers of goods and services in Jamaica. Also, that the insurance industry is not exempted from that law.
Part I, Subsection 3(1) of the CPA, says it “shall apply to all persons involved in trade or business, whether through the purchasing or vending of goods or services”.
Consumer, in relation to services, means any person who employs or wishes to be provided with the service, and services are defined as “the supply to a consumer of anything for a consideration”.
Consideration is a legal term for money.
The law defines ‘provider’ in relation to any service as “a person who provides such services”.
The intention is crystal clear. Our lawmakers intended for it to apply to insurance transactions. The persons who do not like me – supposedly, unbiased insurance company employees – presumably, have not taken the time to read the writings of Mr Savage and carefully thought about their significance against the background of the CPA.
The CPA is administered by the Consumer Affairs Commission. Subsection 6(1)(a) empowers the commission to “carry out at the request of a consumer who has been adversely affected, such investigations in relation to … the provision of services as will enable it to determine whether … the services were provided in contravention of the Act”.
Subsection 3(b) says that the “commission shall investigate any action alleged in a complaint … to have been taken by a provider, which adversely affects the complainant”.
Finally, the CPA says in Subsection 7(1): “A complaint to the commission may be made by any person or body of persons who claims to have suffered a disadvantage in relation to the acquisition of goods or service.”
It is, therefore, possible for any insurance consumer like me to file a complaint against his insurance company with the CAC. It would have to show that the consumer suffered an economic disadvantage in terms of higher motor insurance premiums over the last five to 10 years, for example, as a direct result of his insurer’s strategy.
That argument could be strengthened by referring to the exact words of IAJ vice-president Peter Levy, published in this newspaper on May 1, 2015.
“To the extent that fraudulent claims occur, and we are unable to prove them to be fraudulent, we ultimately have to collect premiums to pay for them and so it does impact on the ordinary consumers and innocent consumers, have to pay,” Levy said.
If fair treatment of consumers was at the heart of insurance, the practice would have been abandoned a long time ago.
Is the practice of charging honest insurance consumers for the estimated $10 billion losses due to fraud between 2008 and 2012 yet another example of what Mr Savage calls insurers abusing their “position of strength” against all honest consumers? Should the authorities intervene? Or should insurers act in their own self-interests and formulate a fairer strategy to combat fraud?
Since this is my last article for 2017, I extend best wishes to all my readers, including those in the insurance industry, for a happy and prosperous 2018.
– Cedric E. Stephens provides independent information and advice about the management of risks and insurance. For free information or counsel, write to: [email protected]
CARACAS.- La espera terminó y los Rays de Tampa Bay, en teoría, reforzaron la posición que menos le estaba aportando a la ofensiva con el regreso del criollo Wilson Ramos a las mayores. ?Estamos felices por tener a Wilson Ramos con nosotros? , dijo Kevin Cash a MLB.com. ?Me imagino que probablemente tenía algunas inquietudes…
La compraventa de inmuebles como Torre Agbar, Xanadú y el Edificio España aumenta un 70% la inversión en el primer semestre hasta los 6.000 millones de euros. La inversión inmobiliaria vuelve a registrar cifras récord en el mercado español. A falta de apenas cuatro días del cierre del semestre, la compraventa de edificios y solares…
san fernando Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley prayed with members of the Muslim community and distributed zakat (charity) to the needy as he celebrated Eid-ul-Fitr at two masjids in San Fernando yesterday. He attended the Eid services on an invitation from Minister of Local Government Kazim Hosein, who is also referred to as a…
gasparillo The mother of a disabled child was shot dead inside her apartment in Gasparillo yesterday. Ornella Philips, 28, was shot once in the chest. Her body was discovered lying in the living room around 10 a.m. The country’s murder toll now stands at 243. Her eight-year-old daughter, Kayla, has cerebral palsy and depends…
ISTANBUL (AP): Turkish police stopped activists for lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans and intersex rights from gathering in large numbers for an LGBT Pride event in Istanbul yesterday, but smaller groups made impromptu press statements, defying a ban imposed by the governor. Organisers of the 2017 Istanbul LGBTI+ Pride had vowed to march in central Taksim…
LONDON (AP): The list of high-rise apartment towers in Britain that have failed fire-safety tests grew to 60, officials said yesterday, revealing the mounting challenge the government faces in the aftermath of London’s Grenfell Tower fire tragedy. All of the buildings for which external cladding samples were so far submitted failed combustibility tests, Communities Secretary…
BAHAWALPUR (AP): Alerted by an announcement over a mosque’s loudspeaker that an overturned tanker truck had sprung a leak, scores of villagers raced to the scene with fuel containers yesterday to gather the oil. Then the wreck exploded, engulfing people in flames as they screamed in terror. At least 153 men, women and children were…
WASHINGTON (AP): Making a final push, United States President Donald Trump said he doesn’t think congressional Republicans are “that far off” on a health overhaul to replace “the dead carcass of Obamacare”. Expressing frustration, he complained about “the level of hostility” in government and wondered why both parties can’t work together on the Senate bill…
While reliving the horrors experienced by so many families after another spate of bizarre violence across the country last week, I couldn’t help but picture Tourism Minister Ed Bartlett’s rictus grin plastered on television screens while the elderly and even suckling babes were being gruesomely slaughtered inside their homes. While the rest of us were…
- 20 January, 2018 Publix pharmacies offer new low-price prescription drug program
- 20 January, 2018 Publix pharmacies offer new low-price prescription drug program
- 20 January, 2018 Government shutdown begins and so does the finger-pointing
- 20 January, 2018 Across the globe, rallies against Trump, sexual misconduct
- 20 January, 2018 Government shutdown: What's closed, who's affected
- 20 January, 2018 US Navy 'shadowing' Russian spy ship in Caribbean Sea
- 20 January, 2018 The train will return, tourism minister assures Appleton boss
- 20 January, 2018 Early lockdown – State of emergency tightens grip on St James
- 20 January, 2018 Gov't offers early retirement programme to some public sector workers
- 20 January, 2018 Marvellous Marva ready to complete hat-trick